Thanksgiving Menu, NYC

1299 Second Avenue
New York, NY 10065

Order Now
Call: (212) 737-0600

Grace’s Marketplace will be closed on Thanksgiving Day!
All orders must be placed by 3:00pm, Monday (Nov. 23).
Any changes or additions must be made by Tuesday (Nov. 24).
Deliveries will be made on Wednesday (Nov. 25).

10AM – 1PM or 2PM – 6PM

Print Menu


Deviled Eggs $25/dz
Sweet & Spicy or topped w/chopped Cranberries

Mini-Arancini (rice balls) $28/dz
Stuffed w/Mozzarella, Mushrooms

Grilled Jumbo Butterflied Shrimp $38/dz
Wrapped w/Scallion

Mini-Baked Stuffed Brie $28/dz
w. Cranberries & Walnuts

Spinach & Artichoke Dip $12/pt
w. Pita Crisps



Cream of Butternut Squash $7.50/pt.

Pumpkin Soup $7.50/pt.

Cream of Broccoli $8/pt.



Sausage & Herb $9.99/lb.

Chestnuts w. Scallion $9.99/lb.

Cornbread w. Walnut & Raisins $9.99/lb.

Apple & Apricot  $9.99/lb

Wild Rice Stuffing w. Chestnuts $13.99/lb.



Glazed Yams $9.99/lb.

Yams Praline $10.99/lb.

Creamed Spinach $10.99/lb

Yams & Apple Casserole $10.99/lb.

Roasted Butternut Squash $9.99/lb

Herb Roasted Baby Carrots $9.99/lb

Traditional Mashed Potatoes $9.99/lb.

Roasted Brussels Sprouts $11.99/lb
w. Chestnuts

Acorn Squash Halves $9/lb
Stuffed w. Cranberries

Pumpkin Ravioli $10.99/lb
w. Brown Butter Sage Sauce

Broccoli Cheese Casserole  $14.99/lb



Whole Roast Turkey (raw weight) $7/lb
w. Giblet Gravy

Sliced Boneless Turkey Breast $17.99/lb
w. Giblet Gravy

Grilled Skirt Steak $32/lb
w. Sautéed Onions

Bone-In Spiral Ham $11.99/lb
Topped w. Pineapple or Honey Maple Glaze

Cornish Game Hen $9.99/lb
Stuffed with Cornbread Stuffing

Rosemary & Garlic Roasted Salmon $33.99/lb


Sauces & Relishes

Giblet Gravy $7/pt.

Cranberry Orange Relish $8/pt.

Cranberry Conserve $8/lb.

Spiced Cranberry Conserve $8/lb.

Apple Sauce w/ Cinnamon Sticks $7/pt.



5” Pecan Pie
10”Pecan Pie

5” Apple Pie
10” Apple Lattice Pie

5” Pumpkin Pie
10” Pumpkin Pie

5” Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

5” Three Berry Pie

10” Apple Crumb Pie