Rosh Hashanah Menu – NYC

1299 2nd Avenue
New York, NY

Order Now
Call: 212-737-0600
Email: GracesCaterNYC@gmail.com

Rosh Hashanah begins on September 22nd, and ends on the evening of September 24th. All orders will be taken according to the discretion and capacity of the catering department. All confirmed orders must be finalized by 12 pm, September 20th. Any order changed or canceled after this date and time will be charged in full. Credit cards are required to confirm any, and all orders.

Pick up orders 9am – 6pm.
Delivery windows are from 10 am – 1 pm & 2 pm – 6 pm.


Starters

Potato Latke $14.99/lb
Potato OR Sweet Potato

Matzo Ball Soup $12/pt • $20/qt

Vegetarian Lentil Soup $10/pt • $18/qt

Matzo Balls $2.50 each

Chopped Chicken Liver
$16/pt • $32/qt

Gefilte Fish – Red or White Horseradish
3 pcs $16 • 6 pcs $32 • 9 pcs $48 • 12 pcs $64

Holiday Crudite $95
Raw Vegetable arrangement served with Smoked Salmon Everything Dip, Hummus, Olives
One Size Serves 10-12
Dill Sauce ½ pint $8.00 ea

Round Challah $18 each

Stuffed Cabbage Rolls
Sirloin and Rice
3 pcs $12 • 6 pcs $24 • 9 pcs $36 • 12 pcs $48


Gravy, Sauces and Conserve

Giblet Gravy $10/pt

Brisket Gravy $10/pt • $19/qt

Hearty Mushroom Gravy $14/pt • $26/qt

Cranberry Conserve $10/pt • $20/qt

Apple Sauce $12/pt • $22/qt

Entrees

First Cut Beef Brisket
Served with Natural Gravy, Potatoes, and Carrots
Sm $90 • Med $135 • LG $180 • XL $360

Skirt Steak Grilled
with Hearty Mushroom Gravy
Sm $80 • Med $120 • LG $160 • XL $320

Glazed Cornish Hen Halves $15.00 each
with Challah Apricot and Apple Stuffing

Chicken Romano Meatballs
Served with Stewed Tomato, Basil and Mozzarella
Sm $30 • Med $45 • LG $75 • XL $120

Whole Roasted Turkey – Starting at 10 lbs
Herb Roasted Turkey served w. Giblet Gravy
10-12 lbs $145 • 14-16 lbs $190 • 18-20 lbs $240 • 22-24 lbs $285
Carved Whole Turkey, White & Dark Meat +$25 Service Charge

Sliced Roast Turkey Breast
Herb Roasted served w. Giblet Gravy
Sm $40 • Med $60 • LG $120 • XL $160

Organic Roasted Chicken, cut 1/8 $22.00 each
Rubbed with Fresh Herbs and Lemon

Baked Salmon Filet
with Lemon, Honey and Thyme
2 pcs $38 • 4 pcs $75 • 10 pcs $190

Accompaniments and Signature Side Dishes 

Carrot and Sweet Potato Tzimmes,
Honey Glaze, Prunes
S $30 • M $45 • L $75 • XL $120

Stem Carrots and Parsnips
with Honey & Sage
S $30 • M $45 • L $75 • XL $120

Yukon Gold Lemon Potato
S $25 • M $39 • L $80 • XL $105

KUGEL Varieties
• Noodle
• Potato or Sweet Potato
• Leek and Mushroom
S $30 • M $45 • L $75 • XL $120

Warm Couscous and Chick Peas
with Zucchini, Lemon, Herbs
S $30 • M $45 • L $60 • XL $120

Roasted String Bean and Beets
S $30 • M $45 • L $75 • XL $120

Whipped Sweet Potato with Marshmallow
S $25 • M $39 • L $80 • XL $105

Oven Roasted Vegetable
S $32 • M $48 • L $80 • XL $125

Signature Kale Parmesan Salad
Serves: 4-6 $40 • 10-12 $60 • 20-25 $90

Holiday Dinner Packages

There are no substitutions to any package. Packages can be increased in intervals of 5 guests

Classic Holiday Dinner Package

$69/guest Starting at 5 guests

Fresh Challah
Matzo Ball Soup with 1 Matzo Ball per guest
Potato Latke
Choice of Potato OR Sweet Potato
Apple Sauce

First Cut Beef Brisket w. Gravy on the side
Organic Roast Chicken, Fresh Herbs and Lemon

Whipped Sweet Potato with Marshmallow
Choice of Kugel
Apple Pie

Signature Dinner Package

$72/guest Starting at 5 guests

Fresh Challah
Matzo Ball Soup
with 1 Matzo Ball per guest
Chopped Chicken Liver

Sliced Turkey Breast, Giblet Gravy
Baked Salmon Filet, 8oz Filet

Stem Carrots and Parsnips
Choice of Kugel
Oven Roasted Vegetables
Fresh Fruit Platter

Prime Meat Specialties

Cleaned, Seasoned and Ready for Roasting.
These items are RAW. Grace’s family recipe cooking instructions will be provided

Whole Turkey $12/lb
with Fresh Garlic Rub, White Wine, Salt and Pepper
10-12 lbs · 14-16 lbs · 18-20 lbs · 20-22 lbs

Turkey Breast $15/lb
with Fresh Garlic Rub, White Wine, Salt and Pepper
Approx 5 – 6 lbs

Whole Chicken, Free Range $8/lb
Savory Herbs, Fresh Lemon, Fresh Garlic Rub, Salt and Pepper
Approx 4 – 4 ½ lbs each

Salmon Filet 8 oz each $30/lb
Lemon, Honey and Herbs Marinade

Dessert and Fresh Fruit

Apple Tart (8 inch) $30 each

Apple Pie or Apple Crumb Pie (10 inch) $30 each

Sponge Cake: Plain or Marble

Honey Cake

Fresh Fruit Platter, Sliced 
Sm serves 8-10 $75 • Med serves 15 $115 • Lg serves 20-22 $150

Fruit Salad
Sm serves 4-6 $30 • Med serves 10-12 $55 • Lg serves 18-20 $105

Rainbow Cookies $22/lb

Rugalach, Assorted Variety $24/lb


Small serves 2-3 – Approx. 2 lbs
Medium serves 5-6 – Approx. 3 lbs
Large serves 8-10 – Approx. 5 lbs
XL serves 16-18 – Approx. 8 lbs

All Prices are subject to change with market fluctuation.
Refer to the catering team for additional questions.