Christmas Menu, NYC

1299 Second Avenue
New York, NY 10065

Order now
Call: (212) 737-0600
Email: GracesCaterNYC@gmail.com

All orders must be placed and finalized by Friday, December 20th. There will be no changes after this time. A credit card must be provided to confirm. Any Orders changed or canceled will be charged in full after Saturday, Dec 21st. All prices are subject to change.

All orders fulfilled on Tuesday, December 24th
Pick Up orders: 9 am – 6 pm
Delivery Windows: 10 am – 1 pm OR 2 pm – 6 pm

Starters

Stuffed Mushroom $30/dz
with Italian Sausage and Broccoli Rabe, Pecorino

Spinach and Artichoke Dip $15/pt $30/qt
• Add Grace’s Chips $3.99 each
• Add Crostini $3.99 each

Jumbo Poached Shrimp $42/dz
2 dz minimum for plattering

Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes $84/dz
with Red Pepper Remoulade

Grandma Grace’s Signature Baked Clams $36/dz

Mini Polpette Pomodoro $30/dz
Beef, Pork and Veal

Petit Lamb Chops with Mint Pesto $65/lb – MP
Approx. 5-6 per lb

Pasta

Minimum order is 2 lbs, increases in 1 lb intervals.

Manicotti with Herb Ricotta $14/lb

Penne Alla Vodka $14/lb
with Pancetta

Orecchiette $15/lb
with Broccoli Rabe

Pappardelle with Lobster Sauce $28/lb

Fettucine Alfredo with Shrimp $24/lb

Lobster Ravioli in Vodka Sauce $24/lb

Lasagna Bolognese
Half Tray serves 8-10 $85

Entrees

Minimum order is 2 lbs, increases in 1 lb intervals.

Filet Mignon $70/lb
with Mushroom and Shallot Au Jus
8oz each

Classic Veal Piccata $45/lb

Spiral Ham
with Orange and Maple Glaze $18/lb

Fried Filet of Sole $57.50/lb
with Tartar Sauce and Lemon Wedges

Parmesan Panko Chicken Milanese $16/lb
Bruschetta on the side

Jumbo Shrimp Scampi $42/lb

Stuffed Pork Tenderloin $21/lb
with Spinach, Sundried Tomato and Mozzarella

Sliced Turkey Breast $21.99/lb
with Giblet Gravy

Accompaniments and Classic Sides

Creamed Spinach
Sm $32 · Med $50 · Lg $80

Grilled Asparagus with Shaved Parmesan
Sm $36 · Med $54 · Lg $90

Mashed Potato, Plain or Garlic
Sm $24 · Med $36 · Lg $60

Roasted Butternut Squash, Cranberries
Sm $24 · Med $36 · Lg $60

Sweet Potato Wedge
Sm $24 · Med $36 · Lg $60

String Bean, Garlic and Oil
Sm $30 · Med $45 · Lg $75

Honey Dijon Brussel Sprouts
Sm $26 · Med $39 · Lg $65

Yukon Gold Home fries
Sm $24 · Med $36 · Lg $60

Holiday Stuffing

Small serves 2-3 – Approx. 2 lbs
Medium serves 5-6 – Approx. 3 lb
Large serves 8-10 – Approx. 5 lb

Sm $26 · Med $39 · Lg $78

  • Sausage and Herb
  • Cornbread with Walnut & Raisin

Sm $36 · Med $54 · Lg $110

  • Wild Rice and Chestnut
  • Chestnut Scallion

Dessert

Buche de Noel (Pre-Order by 12/20)

Apple Lattice Pie 5″ $16 / 10″ $30

Apple Crumb Pie 10” $28

Tiramisu Cake $36

8 inch Fruit Tarts $40 each
Mixed Fruit OR Raspberry

Cannoli

Fruit Platter, Freshly Sliced
Sm $70 · Med $105 · Lg $140
Sm serves 10
Med serves 15
Lg serves 20

Holiday Panettone or Pandoro $40 each

Christmas Dinner Packages

There are no substitutions to any package

Basic Dinner Package
4 guests $299 6 guests $365 10 guests $549

Spinach and Artichoke Dip – Crostini OR Chips
Mini Polpette
Penne a la Vodka, Pancetta and Peas
Parmesan Panko Chicken Milanese, Bruschetta
Spiral Ham
Mashed Potato, Plain OR Garlic
String Bean, Garlic and Oil
Cannoli
Tiramisu Cake

Grace’s Signature Christmas Dinner
4 guests $340 6 guests $469 10 guests $679

Stuffed Mushroom – Sausage, Broc Rabe, Pecorino
Grandma Grace’s Signature Baked Clams
Crepe Manicotti
Jumbo Shrimp Scampi
Stuffed Pork Tenderloin
Grilled Asparagus
Mashed Potato, Plain OR Garlic
10 inch Fruit Tart:
• Mixed Fruit • Raspberry

Prime Meat Specialties

RAW Cleaned, Seasoned and Ready for Roasting
Grace’s family recipe cooking instructions will be provided

Prime Rib Roast, Bone in $44.99/lb

Crown Rack of Lamb $44.99/lb
Rosemary, Cracked Pepper and Sea Salt, Onion and Fresh Garlic

Whole Filet Mignon $51.99/lb
Fresh Garlic Rub, Dijon, Parsley, Salt and Pepper
Available in: 3 lbs 4 lbs 5 lbs

Bone in Pork Loin $8.99/lb
Brown Sugar, Honey and Garlic Rub