Thanksgiving Menu, Greenvale

81 Glen Cove Road
Greenvale, NY 11548

Order Now
Call: 516-621-5100
Email: CateringLongIsland@GracesMarketplace.com

Grace’s Marketplace will be closed on Thanksgiving Day!
Orders will be taken according the capacity and discretion of the catering
department. All CONFIRMED orders can be changed until 12 pm, Friday,
11/20/25.
All orders fulfilled on Wednesday (Nov. 25)

DELIVERY on 11/25
8AM – 1PM or 3PM – 8PM

PICK UP AVAILABLE on 11/25
9AM – 1PM or 3PM – 8PM

A credit card must be provided to confirm. Any cancellation made after Sunday, 11/22/26, 12 pm will be charged in full. There are no exceptions. Orders are taken and processed through the catering department.


Thanksgiving a la Carte Menu

Serving Size Guide: Small: 2 – 3 · Medium: 4 – 6 · Large: 10 – 12 · XL: 16 – 18

Starters

Garden Medley Crudite Platter
With Hummus, Babaganoush, Dill Sauce
Serves 10 – 12, $95

Arancini
with Mushroom and Mozzarella
$30/dozen

Artichoke & Parmesan Dip
$15/pt, $29/qt
Add Crostini $5 each
Add Grace’s Chips $8 each

Crispy Panko Sweet Potato Croquettes
$30/dozen

Petit Meatballs $36/dozen

  • Thanksgiving Turkey – Cranberry, Stuffing, Herbs and Gravy
  • Vegetarian Eggplant

Pigs in Blanket
with Grain Mustard
$27/dozen

Petit Spanakopita
$24/dozen

Soups Pint $7 · Quart $14

  • Cream of Butternut Squash
  • Mushroom Barley
  • Tomato Bisque
  • Corn Chowder

Salad

Sm $40 (Serves 4-6)
Med $60 (Serves 8-10)
Lg $100 (Serves 22-25)

Signature Kale Parmesan Salad
Cranberry, Almonds, Parmesan

Savory Arugula
Roasted Beets, Goat Cheese, Pecans, Apple

Stuffing

Small $25 · Medium $40 · Large $60 · XL $115

  • Cornbread, Raisin
  • Sausage & Herb

Small $35 · Medium $55 · Large $75 · XL $145

  • Chestnut Scallion
  • Butternut Squash, Quinoa and Kale (GF)

Gravy & Conserve Pint $8 · Quart $15

  • House made Giblet Gravy
  • Cranberry Conserve (contains nuts)
  • Spiced Cranberry Conserve with Pecans
  • Cranberry Orange Conserve
  • Apple Sauce with Cinnamon
  • Beef Gravy
    Pint $8.50 · Qt $16.00
  • Puree of Mushroom Gravy (V)
    Rich Mushroom Broth w. Vegetable Stock, Herbs
    Pint $8.50 · Qt $16.00

Entrees

Roast Turkey, Whole
Giblet Gravy on the side
10-12 lbs $135 · 14-16 lbs $180 · 18-20 lbs $220 · 22-24 lbs $275
CARVED off the frame +$25 Service Charge

Sliced Turkey Breast
Giblet Gravy on the side
Sm $30 · Med $60 · Lg $85 · XL $170

Baked Ham
Sm $28.50 · Med $55 · Lg $75 · XL $155

Sliced TriTip Steak
with Sauteed Vidalia Onion and Shallot
Sm $36 · Med $70 · Lg $95 · XL $190

Slow Cooked Brisket Meatballs in Classic Gravy
Sm $48 · Med $90 · Lg $125 · XL $215

Roasted Salmon Filet
in Lemon and White Wine Sauce
2 pcs $38 · 4 pcs $76 · 10 pcs $190

Lasagna with Spinach Ricotta
Lg $70 · XL $130

Sides: Vegetable and Starches

Roasted Stem Carrots with Fresh Herbs and Butter
Sm $30 · M $45 · Lg $75 · XL $120

String Beans OR Broccoli
Choice of: Garlic Oil or Almondine
Sm $30 · M $45 · Lg $75 · XL $120

Honey Dijon Brussel Sprout
Sm $30 · M $45 · Lg $75 · XL $120

Traditional Mashed Potatoes
Sm $25 · M $35 · Lg $60 · XL $100

Glazed Yams with Cinnamon Sugar, Brown Butter
Sm $26 · M $39 · Lg $75 · XL $115

Whipped Sweet Potato with Marshmallow
Sm $26 · M $39 · Lg $75 · XL $115

Classic Mac and Cheese made with Fusilli
Sm $26 · M $39 · Lg $75 · XL $115

Desserts

White Post Farms Pies $35

  • Apple Pie
  • Apple Crumb Pie
  • Pumpkin Pie
  • Pecan Pie
  • Blueberry Crumb Pie
  • Cherry Pie
  • Salted Caramel Apple with Pretzel Streusel Crust

Briermere Farms $55 (Order by 11/19)

  • Chocolate Cream Pie
  • Blueberry Cream
  • Raspberry Cream
  • Coconut Meringue

Featured Cakes and Loaves

  • Carrot Cake (8 inch) $50
  • Cornbread Loaf $13
  • Pumpkin Loaf $13

Fresh Cut Fruit

Four Berry Salad
Small $60 · Medium $120 · Large $150

Fruit Salad
Small $30 · Medium $70 · Large $120

Fruit Platter
Small $69.50 (serves 10)
Medium $99.50 (serves 15)
Large $129.50 (serves 20)
XL $155 (serves 30)

Thanksgiving Dinner Packages

All Packages are a set selection and made for a minimum of 10 guests, upgraded to 15, 20 guests. A la Carte items are available in addition to any package. There are no substitutions or alterations to set packages.


RAW TURKEY, Prepped and Oven Ready
$379
Whole Turkey or Turkey Breast, seasoned and Oven Ready.
Cooking Instructions provided.

House made Giblet Gravy (GF)
Cream of Butternut Squash OR Corn Chowder
Cornbread OR Sausage Stuffing
Traditional Mashed Potato OR Whipped Sweet Potato
Choice of White Post Farms Pie

Classic Dinner $575
Artichoke & Parmesan Dip
Petit Meatballs – Turkey or Eggplant
Cream of Butternut Squash Soup
Whole Roast Turkey w. Gravy (16 lbs)
Choice of Stuffing
Traditional Mashed Potato
Grace’s Signature Kale Salad
Choice of White Post Farms Pie

Everything but the Bird $400
(Vegetarian Friendly Feast)
Artichoke & Parmesan Dip
Vegetarian Eggplant Meatballs
Corn Chowder
Classic Mac and Cheese OR Lasagna
Honey Dijon Brussel Sprouts
Roasted Stem Carrots
Grace’s Signature Kale Salad
Choice of White Post Farms Pie

Elegant Dinner $895
Garden Medley Crudite
Crispy Panko Sweet Potato Croquette
Petit Spanakopita
Tomato Bisque OR Cream of Butternut Squash
Choice of Stuffing
Sliced TriTip Steak with Mushroom and Onion
Roasted Salmon Filet, 10 pcs
Roasted Stem Carrot
String Bean OR Broccoli
Glazed Yams OR Whipped Sweet Potato with Marshmallow
Choice of White Post Farms Pie

All Prices are subject to change. There are no customizations to any dish or package. Thank you.

Our Customers Love Us

Let us bring the best of what our market has to offer to your doorstep! Start your order now.
[instagram-feed]