Thanksgiving Menu, NYC

1299 Second Avenue
New York, NY 10065

Order Now
Call: (212) 737-0600
Email: GracesCaterNYC@gmail.com

Grace’s Marketplace will be closed on Thanksgiving Day!
All orders must be placed and finalized by Wednesday (Nov. 25).
There will be no changes after this time. A credit card must be provided to confirm. All prices are subject to change.
All orders fulfilled on Wednesday, November 25th.

DELIVERY WINDOWS
10AM – 1PM or 2PM – 6PM


Starters

Crispy Panko Sweet Potato Croquettes $30 per dozen

Spinach & Artichoke Dip $15/pt, $30/qt
add Crostini $3.99 each

Jumbo Poached Shrimp Platter $44 per dozen
with homemade cocktail sauce

Arancini $30 per dozen
with Mushroom and Mozzarella

Potato Latke $14.99 per lb

Petit Turkey Meatballs $15 per lb
with Cranberry Glaze

Stuffed Mushroom $30 per dozen
with Italian Sausage and Peppers

Soups

Cream of Butternut Squash $9/pt, $18/qt

Pumpkin Bisque $9/pt, $18/qt

Corn Cowder $9/pt, $18/qt

Carrot and Ginger $9/pt, $18/qt

Stuffing

Small 2lbs · Medium 3lbs · Large 5lbs

Small $26 · Medium $39 · Large $65

  • Sausage & Herb
  • Cornbread with Walnut & Raisin
  • Apple and Cranberry

Small $36 · Medium $54 · Large $90

  • Wild Rice and Chestnut

Accompaniments

Potatoes and Starches
Small 2 lbs · Medium 3 lbs · Large 5 lbs

Small $26 · Medium $39 · Large $65

  • Glazed Yams
  • Roasted Butternut Squash & Beets
  • Classic Mashed Potatoes
  • Whipped Sweet Potatoes topped with Marshmallow

Small $30 · Medium $45 · Large $75

  • Classic Mac and Cheese
  • Pumpkin Ravioli in Brown Butter Sage Sauce
  • Lasagna with Spinach and Ricotta

Vegetables
Small 2 lbs · Medium 3 lbs · Large 5 lbs

Small $30 · Medium $45 · Large $75

  • Grilled Asparagus with Lemon
  • Honey Roasted Carrots
  • String Bean Almondine
  • Brussel Sprout with Chestnuts

Acorn Squash $14 each
stuffed with fresh cranberries

Corn Bread $4.50 each

Entrees

Minimum order is 2 lbs, increases in 1 lb intervals, excluding Whole and Carved Turkey.

Roast Turkey, Whole $12 per lb
Giblet Gravy on the side

Sliced Turkey Breast $21.99 per lb
Giblet Gravy on the side

Mushroom Bourguignon $18 per lb
with Carrots, Red Wine, Pearl Onions

Filet Mignon $60 per lb
with Red Wine Reduction

Pork Loin $21.99 per lb
stuffed with Cranberries and Apples

Baked Honey Maple Glazed Spiral Ham
with Pineapple and Honey Maple Glaze
$19.99 per lb off the bone, $95 whole

Cornish Hens $17 each
stuffed with Wild Rice Stuffing

Roasted Salmon Filet $38 per lb
In Lemon and White Wine Sauce

Uncooked Protein

Whole Turkey, RAW $8.99 per lb
Seasoned and Oven Ready
10 lbs · 15 lbs · 20 lbs · 25 lbs

Whole Turkey Breast, RAW $15 per lb
Seasoned and Oven Ready
Approx 5-6 lbs

Whole Filet Mignon, RAW $55 per lb
Seasoned and Oven Ready
Available in 3 lbs – 4 lbs – 5 lbs

Signature Dinner Package

10 guests $575

Artichoke and Parmesan Dip with Crostini

Crispy Panko Sweet Potato Croquettes 24pc

Cream of Butternut Squash Soup 6 pts

Whole Roast Turkey 15 lbs
with Giblet Gravy

Choice of Stuffing Large

Classic Mashed Potato Large

Grace’s Signature Kale Salad 3 lb

Choice of Pie 10 inch

Gravy & Relish

Giblet Gravy $10/pt, $20/qt

Mushroom Gravy $12/pt, $24/qt

Classic Apple Sauce $12/pt, $24/qt

Cranberry Conserve $12/pt, $24/qt

Cranberry Orange Conserve $12/pt, $24/qt

Spiced Cranberry Conserve $12/pt, $24/qt

Pies and Dessert Platters

Pear Amaretti $9 each

Roma Apple Stuffed $9 each
with almond paste and cinnamon

Pecan Pie 5 inch $16 · 10 inch $32

Apple Lattice Pie 10 inch $32

Apple Crumb Pie 10 inch $32

Classic Pumpkin Pie
5 inch $16 · 10 inch $32

Harvest Pie 10 inch $32
with apples, peach, walnuts & cranberries

Coconut Custard Pie 10 inch $32

Blueberry Pie 10 inch $32

Fruit Platter, Freshly Sliced
Small $80 · Medium $120 · Large $160

Our Customers Love Us

Let us bring the best of what our market has to offer to your doorstep! Start your order now.
[instagram-feed]