Thanksgiving Menu, NYC

1299 Second Avenue
New York, NY 10065

Order Now
Call: (212) 737-0600
Email: GracesCaterNYC@gmail.com

Grace’s Marketplace will be closed on Thanksgiving Day!
All orders must be placed and finalized by Sunday (Nov. 24).
There will be no changes after this time. A credit card must be provided to confirm. Orders will be charged in full after Sunday, Nov 24. All prices are subject to change.
All Orders will be dispatched on Wednesday (Nov. 27).

DELIVERY TIMES
10AM – 1PM or 2PM – 6PM


Starters

Spinach & Artichoke Dip $15/pt, $30/qt
add Crostini $3.99 each
add Grace’s Chips $3.99 each

Lump Crab Cakes $72
per dozen Garden Aioli

Jumbo Poached Shrimp Platter (MP)
2 dozen $84 · 3 dozen $126 · 4 dozen $168

Arancini $30 per dozen
with Roasted Peppers and Mozzarella

Sweet & Spicy Deviled Eggs
$27 per dozen

Stuffed Mushroom $30 per dozen
with Italian Sausage and Peppers

Sweet and Savory Tartlet $40.00 each
Pear, Brie and Rosemary on Flaky Puffed Pastry (serves 6 – 8)

Soups

Cream of Butternut Squash $9/pt, $17/qt

Pumpkin Bisque $9/pt, $17/qt

Potato Leek $9/pt, $17/qt

Stuffing

Small 2lbs · Medium 3lbs · Large 6lbs

Small $26 · Medium $39 · Large $78

  • Sausage & Herb
  • Cornbread with Walnut & Raisin
  • Apple and Cranberry

Small $36 · Medium $54 · Large $110

  • Wild Rice and Chestnut
  • Chestnut Scallion

Accompaniments

Potatoes and Starches
Small 1.5 lbs · Medium 3 lbs · Large 5 lbs

Small $18 · Medium $36 · Large $60

  • Glazed Yams
  • Roasted Butternut Squash & Carrot
  • Classic Mashed Potatoes
  • Whipped Sweet Potatoes with Marshmallow

Small $30 · Medium $45 · Large $90

  • Fusilli Mac and Cheese
  • Pumpkin Ravioli in Brown Butter Sage Sauce
  • Quinoa with Mushroom and Pearl Onion

Vegetables
Small 2 lbs · Medium 3 lbs · Large 5 lbs

Small $30 · Medium $45 · Large $90

  • Creamed Spinach
  • Herb Roasted Stem Carrot
  • Roasted String Bean with Parmesan Panko
  • Honey Roasted Brussel Sprouts

Acorn Squash $10 each
with fresh cranberries

Entrees

Minimum order is 2 lbs, increases in 1 lb intervals, excluding Whole and Carved Turkey.

Roast Turkey, Whole $12 per lb
Giblet Gravy on the side
Sizes: 10-12 lbs · 14-16 lbs · 18-20 lbs · 22-24 lbs

Roast Turkey, CARVED $14 per lb
Giblet Gravy on the side
Sizes: 10-12 lbs · 14-16 lbs · 18-20 lbs · 22-24 lbs

Sliced Turkey Breast $21.99 per lb
Giblet Gravy on the side

Filet Mignon $60.00 per lb
Mushroom Au Jus

Roast Pork Loin $21.99 per lb
with sautéed Apple and Onion

Spiral Ham $18.00 per lb
with Orange Maple Glaze

Cornish Hens $15.00 each
stuffed with Cornbread and Dried Fruit

Roasted Salmon Filet $42.00 per lb

Uncooked Protein

Whole Turkey, RAW $8.49 per lb
Seasoned and Oven Ready
10-12 lbs · 14-16 lbs · 18-20 lbs · 22-24 lbs

Whole Turkey Breast, RAW $14.00 per lb
Seasoned and Oven Ready
Approx 5-6 lbs

Whole Filet Mignon, RAW $51.99 per lb
Seasoned and Oven Ready
Available in 3 lbs – 4 lbs – 5 lbs

Signature Dinner Package

4 guests $375 · 6 guests $495 · 10 guests $755

Spinach and Artichoke Dip
with Crostini OR Grace’s Chips

Cream of Butternut Squash Soup

Whole Roast Turkey with Giblet Gravy – not carved

Choose 1 Stuffing:

  • Sausage & Herb
  • Cornbread Walnut, Raisin
  • Apple Cranberry

Mashed Potatoes

Roasted String Beans with Parmesan Panko

Apple Lattice Pie OR Pumpkin Pie, 10 inch

Gravy & Relish

Giblet Gravy $7.50/pt, $15/qt

Mushroom Gravy $9/pt, $18/qt

Classic Apple Sauce $7/pt

Cranberry Conserve $10/pt

Cranberry Orange Conserve $10/pt

Spiced Cranberry Conserve $10/pt

Pies and Dessert Platters

Apple Crumb Tart 5 inch $16.00

Apple Crumb Pie 10 inch $30.00

Pecan Pie 5 inch $16.00

Classic Apple Pie 5 inch $16.00

Apple Lattice Pie 10 inch $30.00

Classic Pumpkin Pie
5 inch $16.00 · 10 inch $30.00

Carrot Cake 7 inch $32.00

Fruit Platter, Freshly Sliced
Small $75.00 · Medium $115.00 · Large $150.00

Berry Salad
Small $60.00 · Medium $90.00 · Large $150.00